consider two medical tests, a and b, for a virus. test a is 90% effective at recognizing the virus when it is present, but has a 5% false positive rate (indicating that the virus is present, when it is not). test b is 95% effective at recognizing the virus, but has a 10% false positive rate. the two tests use independent methods of identifying the virus. the virus is carried by 2% of all people.Say that a person is tested for the virus using only one of the tests, and that test comes back positive for carrying the virus.Which test returning positive is more indicative of someone really carrying the virus? Justify your answer mathematically (i.e. writing down your calculations).

Respuesta :

We observe, that P(V|B)>P(V|A), so the person is more likely to have virus, however is still very small probability (only 15%), so in order to confirm illness, he should make one more test.

The area of mathematics known as probability deals with numerical representations of the likelihood that an event will occur or that a statement is true. An event's probability is a number between 0 and 1, where, roughly speaking, 0 denotes the event's impossibility and 1 denotes certainty.

P(V/A)  is not 0.95. It is opposite:

P(A/V)=0.95

From the text we can also conclude, that

P(A/∼V)=0.1

P(B/V)=0.9

P(B/∼V)=0.05

P(V)=0.01

P(∼V)=0.99

P(V/A) is not 0.95. It is opposite:

P(A/V)=0.95

From the text we can also conclude, that

P(A/∼V)=0.1

P(B/V)=0.9

P(B/∼V)=0.05

P(V)=0.01

P(∼V)=0.99

What we need to calculate and compare is P(V/A) and P(V/B)

P(V∩A)=P(A)⋅P(V/A)⇒P(V/A)=P(V∩A)/P(A)

P(V∩A) means, that person has a virus and it is detected, so

P(V∩A)=P(V)⋅P(A/V)

=0.01⋅0.95

=0.0095

P(A) is sum of two options: "Person has virus and it is detected" and "Person has no virus, but it was mistakenly detected", therefore:

P(A)=P(V)⋅P(A/V)+P(∼V)⋅P(A/∼V)=0.01⋅0.95+0.99⋅0.1=0.1085

Dividing those two numbers we obtain

P(V/A)=0.0095/0.1085=0.08755760368663594

Analogically,

P(V/B)=P(V∩B)/P(B)=P(V)⋅P(B/V)/P(V)⋅P(B/V)+P(∼V)⋅P(B/∼V)

=0.01⋅0.9/0.01⋅0.9+0.99⋅0.1

=0.1538461538461539

We see that P(V|B)>P(V|A), meaning the individual is more likely to have a virus, but is still very unlikely (only 15%), therefore person should perform another test to confirm illness.

To learn more about probability visit: brainly.com/question/11234923

#SPJ4